Very weird. I've been using this plugin for about a month and have custom title/meta descriptions on a lot of my pages. It was working up until the other day. Now it is going off the settings in POST TYPES/TAXONOMIES/OTHER.
The plugin did this to my other site also after having it installed for a month, but I didn't pay any attention since it's just a low volume site. But now that it's doing it on my main site, this obviously brings an issue. Is there any known bugs for this? I am using the latest of everything. "Force rewrite titles" is checked. Not sure what else would be causing this issue.